blogger profileblogger profile
Krrobi
Teacher / Writer
blog entryblog entry

Calling All Editors!

Wednesday, October, 29, 2008

 

I’ve been severely disciplined.  Not because of my use of content, which can sometimes be over passionate and excessively zealous, or my lack of content, which can at times be underdeveloped and skeletal.  I wasn’t even disciplined because I exploit all of my friends and co-workers (those poor sods) as characters in my blogs.  Nope.  I was slapped on both hands because of my editing skills, which I do not have; my extreme use of commas, my adoration for the semicolon (ohhh, how I looove semi-colons), and even the words I create along the way to make them fit into my stories. To be honest, the reason I love writing for Skirt is because of its non-threatening, non-judgmental, liberating views.  I feel free. I feel as if I’ve found my true voice; I feel as if I can let my hair down, and for the life of me, I cannot understand why somebody (you know whom you are) would give a damn about where I place my commas or semicolons.

 

Professor So and So, from Saint Scholasitca, whom reads my blogs asks, “Why are you using semicolons when you should be beginning another sentence?  And by god, why are you continually using ellipses………………?  It gets confusing.”  I told him I’m not in college anymore so who cares, and why should he care anyhow since I’m not in his class any longer, and isn’t writing a blog about freedom and independence? I told him that although I appreciate his criticism (not really) that I if I were obsessed with commas and semicolons ………………ellipses, and other grammatical errors, I would be inhibited, restrained; I would feel as if I could not write in the way I want to write.  I told him that I understand the basic, boring concept of grammar, but look at Dickenson; she wrote her poetry with dashes all the time, and what about EE Cummings, he NEVER capitalized or use periods.  As I email Professor So and So, I imagine him shaking his head as Reagan did in the debates with Clinton.  Remember when Reagan glanced over at Clinton, smirked, and said “You aren’t Jack Kennedy, sir.”  Anyhow, Professor So and So is shaking his head this minute saying “you aren’t Dickenson or Cummings, that’s for sure, Missy.”

 

Anyhow, I ended up informing him that since I was NOT in his English class; I need not worry about the rules, the stupid dog-gone rules of grammar anymore.  Hell, I’m writing a blog, not a darn dissertation.   And if I were to send something out to a publisher, I would ask him to edit it first, because I AM NOT and never shall be, an editor. These people are like Gods or something.

 

This got me thinking.  I’m good at that (sometimes).  Are others out there in the real world (opposed to the blogging world) thinking the same way as Professor So and So?  Are they looking at my blogs, shaking their English-Teacher-heads, clicking their tongues –exclaiming, “Good story here, but this girl has her possessive adjectives and reflective pronouns all screwed up.  She’s actually a little, well; apparently she’s not as educated or informed as she should be.  Does she even have a college degree...a high school diploma?”

 

The first blog I examined for errors says this: Am I Overeating? (A Freudian slip, perhaps)  I’m appalled; I cringe, because it was supposed to read, Am IOverreacting?  I feel all hot inside, embarrassed.  But how can I find over 100 people who have already read this blog and fix it?  Tell them I meant this and not that!!!   Tell them I have an English degree.  Would they care? Another blog said their rather thanthere.  Too late to go back to edit.  The readers already took note, already formed their first impressions; already think I’m a dork!   Oh, well.

 

Even though Professor So and So irritated me by his criticism, I must admit, he was partly correct about the semicolons.  I’m in love with semicolons; I never want the sentence to end abruptly; I like a slight  pause and then the sentence to continue flowing, flowing, flowingI like the idea of a steady stream of ideas without a conclusion, as if the words will pour out into eternity;  thus, the ellipses…... the commas, and my looover, the semicolon. 

 

And Maybe, Professor So and So, I DO need an editor, a keen eye to MAKE me look at the rules of grammar—make me aware of my distransitive verbs (whatever the hell they are), somebody to make me accountable in some way for my failure of syntax and my overuse of the beautiful semicolon and the comma, one who gives me consequences for this abuse of not conforming.  But in the meantime, I shall kick the crap out of the English language, twist it, mold it, modify it, neglect it, and make it my own.  That’s what I shall do.

 

But mostly, Professor, I WILL JUST WRITE; I WILL SAVOR THE WORDS; I WILL TASTE EACH LETTER;   I WILL ALLOW THE LANGUAGE TO DEVOUR ME, and I will utilize the semicolon and the comma….because I never want the story to END! 

 

 

****Readers, who are your editors?   Do you have others check your work before you send material to the New York Times!?  How many eyes do we need before we send our stories out into the world?  Cheryl?  What do you think, Miss Editor?

 


getaclewis
getaclewis
Posted Wed, 10/29/2008 - 07:20
HAHAHAHA heehee... I got to the end note and cuhracked up! Yes, I've been guilty of making unintentional mental notes, filing away the occasional blog that uses it's when it oughta be its or effects for affects. Ack! But honestly, my skirt!girls get unlimited creative license, since we are all about the REAL on here and REAL AIN'T PERFETC! ;-) I love your writing upside down, inside out, in a box with a fox and pray that you'll just keep on wriiiiiting... and overlook my own blunders! :-D "Trust Life's unfolding..."
MelissaB
MelissaB
Posted Wed, 10/29/2008 - 20:17
I love your writing too. Use as many commas and semi-colons as you wish! That's perfectly fine with me. =) It's funny... when I was thinking about signing up for skirt!, I thought that I wouldn't fit in because I don't have formal training in writing and editing, and I don't have an English degree. I decided that by writing and expressing myself, I would continue to improve. I think one of the best things about this site is that no one is judging anyone else's use of the English language. Keep up the great writing!! p.s. I saw that you live in Duluth, MN. I live in Duluth, GA!
krrobi
krrobi
Posted Thu, 10/30/2008 - 09:48
Duluth, GA!! Awesome, I was hoping you were going to say Duluth, MN!!!! Nice to have you on Skirt!------------- Renee, I looove your sassiness! I looove it! xx
ReneeCK
ReneeCK
Posted Wed, 10/29/2008 - 21:23
Your professor can stuff it because you, too, have a degree from the CK University of Writing. Remember, you take all the undergrad work (which obviously your darling prof is married to) and toss it out the window in order to find your authentic voice. If that means USING ALL CAPS TO MAKE A STATEMENT instead of using and exclaimation point! then so be it!

YOUr blog is about YOU and what YOU are passionate about expressed in YOUr style. If someone else is so stuck up (yeah, I said it proffy, STUCK UP!) to demand that each and every written word follow form and format, then I suggest s/he get a hobby and start living on the wild side. I'd like to see his/her blog about the journey outside the parenthesis.
Renee- writer and WOMAN!
nikki
nikki
Posted Fri, 10/31/2008 - 15:03
There don't seem to be many rules in the blogosphere when it comes to grammar, spelling, punctuation--all the boring bits. But if you ever plan to submit your work for publication, you'll find that editors, including me, can be picky about that. For one thing, we don't have time to vet pieces for elementary-level writing skills, and for another, it's generally considered a mark of disrespect to submit work that isn't clean and well-edited. It's like going to a job interview in cutoffs and flipflops and dirty feet. Of course, if you consider stream of consciousness part of your style, then you will have to take your chances that the editor will also appreciate it. My best writing teacher was rabid about the over-use of exclamation marks because she felt that if you had to resort to using too many, you weren't using your writing skills to convey excitement, terror, passion--whatever. And being able to edit your own work is a crucial skill--almost as important in writing classes as the actual words you use. First you get it all down on paper--that's the passion--and then you have to dispassionately judge your work and get rid of what doesn't advance the piece. It's called "killing your darlings," because you will often have to sacrifice your favorite sentence in order to get the essay as a whole to work. As someone who grew up with Strunk and White, I think ignoring the rules of grammar is like building a house without a foundation or load-bearing walls. There are always rare exceptions like James Joyce, Whitman, Kerouac, who throw the rules out the window. I suspect, though, that before they got rid of the rules, they first learned how to use them! That may be old-fashioned nowadays when email, emoticons and blogs have established different standards for writers. It's just something to consider when it comes to submitting work to print publications. ~nikki
krrobi
krrobi
Posted Sat, 11/01/2008 - 08:52
Nikki, Yes, I have acquired bad habits along the way. I get quite excited when I write, and I am such a rebel, that it has hurt my writing in some ways. Recently I was writing a post and I wanted to write a quote about Natalie Goldberg (about how much she lets go, is free with her writing, has monkey mind, and doesn't care about "the rules.") I started reading some of her books, and the first thing I observed was Natalie writing about how important the "rules of grammar" are. I was like, "Darn it!" ~Then the professor, then you. Somebody is trying to tell me something. I loved your advise. I shall print it out as a reminder and paste to my computer. I shall find my own editors, too! Those unbelievable, beautiful Buddahs. But mostly, out of all of your lovely words, I appreciated "killing your darlings." I find the more I take away, the better the piece is...and sometimes I just looove those "little darlings" to death." Thanks for taking the time to write, Nikki. Oh, one question, do most people edit their own work? ~ Kim
Charlene Ross
Charlene Ross
Posted Mon, 11/03/2008 - 09:00
Kim, you are a girl after my own heart! I know exactly what you mean. I don't edit my blogs very much because I don't have the time, but then I'll think, "Doh, it would have been so much better if I had said this instead of that", etc. My use of grammar in the written word is TERRIBLE. In fact I keep telling myself I have to get my copy of Strunk & White out of whatever box it is in in my garage and read it AGAIN. I too loved what Nikki said about "killing your darlings." (BTW score on Nikki commenting on one of your blogs!) There have been times when I've had to take out the very sentence that started the whole piece. (Damn I hate that!) But yes, I too find that the harder I try to say more with less, the better the piece is. When I do submit something for print I send it to the girls in my writing group for editing - they are not shy in telling me about my overuse of commas, my darling lover parenthises and for the last freaking time it is its not it's!