blogger profileblogger profile
Thatcoolbroad
writer
I'm just a regular gal striving to become "that cool broad." Am I on the right track? Or am I certifiable? You be the judge....
blog entryblog entry

Is gossiping ever okay?

Tuesday, September, 23, 2008

Apparently, gossip makes us happy.

"According to research out of the University of Ghent in Belgium, our brain cells light up in positive ways when we gossip, or tune into tabloids. Gossip is an instant stimulator of endorphins, so when the dirt gets dished, we’re happy campers."*

But does that make gossiping okay?

Even though my disdain with gals who gossip is well documented (check out the following Cool Broad rules here, here, and here), I was intrigued by the premise that we’re naturally predisposed to gossip. Also, I was struck by the fact that when I looked up the word gossip in the dictionary, the definition didn’t capture the mean-spirited or potentially destructive nature that spreading a salacious story often has.

Gossip: idle talk or rumor, especially about the private affairs of others.

And then this weekend, I found myself breaking one of my most important rules: Cool Broads don’t gossip.

This is how it went down: As I chatted with another mom at my son’s soccer game, one of our kids’ team members came up. The reason: he’s a disaster.

This child has routine tantrums in the middle of the game, tells our coach he’s “not a real coach”, grabs the ball and runs off with it, refusing to relinquish it to the referee who is simultaneously chasing the boy and blowing his whistle in frustration, and often just flat out refuses to play if he isn’t happy with how the game is going.

His behavior leaves the other parents on the team with their mouths hanging open, in complete disbelief. His parent’s response….nothing. Nada, not a thing. So naturally, we’re left wondering…what’s going on here?

Anyway, I brought up the child with the other mom and it was only after we clutched each other in camaraderie, relieved that we weren’t the only ones incredulous at the child’s behavior and the parent’s inability (or unwillingness) to keep him from distracting the rest of the team, that I began to feel badly that I was, in effect, gossiping.

Cool Broads don’t gossip, I told myself, so I quickly said to the other mom, “I feel badly about talking about this family behind their backs.”

“I don’t,” she responded, “They deserve it. They’re ruining the experience for everyone else.”

Still, I was talking about the personal affairs of another and I wouldn’t be happy if someone did that to me. It wasn’t mean-spirited and I certainly wasn’t getting a thrill (despite the endorphin-releasing theory), but still, I was conflicted.

So, what do you think? Is gossiping EVER okay?

~tcb
www.thatcoolbroad.com

*FoxNews.com, Health, June 17, 2008
krrobi
krrobi
Posted Tue, 09/23/2008 - 09:53
I am to blame, too. I admit it. And it does feel good to gossip. But then I get this icky feeling, and I think to myself, "Who the hell do I think I am? I am no better than them." I guess we gossip to feel better about ourselves. It's internal. Anyhow, I've definitely been part of that "sport gossip"..."Look at that kid! What the heck is wrong with his parents!?" Cuz I am a perfect parent. NOT! Is gossip ever okay? No. But it still makes one feel good and that's very BAD.
BCBlogger
BCBlogger
Posted Tue, 09/23/2008 - 14:22
Well, see, I don't think what you were doing was exactly GOSSIP. I think you were venting about a frustrating situation and wondering what, exactly, the hell was going on in the parents' heads when they permit little-Johnny-Jerk-Face to act like a brat. To me, there is a difference between "discussion" and "gossip." You were trying to share, you were trying to hammer out a reason for perplexing behavior based on what evidence (little or large) you have. There was a means to an end. Had you been just yammering on about seedy little details of the family in question for no apparent reason, you'd be GUILTY. But you aren't. You didn't. You weren't salaciously whispering about the possibility of Johnny Jerk-Face's mom getting it on with the third grade science teacher, were you? You weren't saying that maybe. . .just maybe. . .the patriarch of the JJF household was hooked on crystal meth and hookers, were ya? No? I didn't think so. I think you should go a little easier on yourself. Gossip, by it's nature, is usually hurtful and done for the dizzying pleasure of making oneself feel superior - either to the object of the gossip or just in a generalized sense. ("I know something you don't know.") I don't think you fit into that category. You're still a COOL BROAD in my book. xoxo
onetwothreebirds
onetwothreebirds
Posted Tue, 09/23/2008 - 18:33

The Communication Studies major in me wants to think this: gossip is probably a leftover from the days of oral communication, when all news-- good and bad-- traveled face-to-face.

The humanist in me thinks: we all know how painful gossip can be when we're the subject of the whispering.

The realist in me knows: I am guilty. But, I am also aware. It is practically impossible not to talk about people in some contexts and all talking-about probably isn't gossip. We can feel better about ourselves by tuning into our message and its tone. A quick and easy way to do that is to ask yourself, "How would I feel if someone was saying this about me?"

The devil's advocate in me knows: We all want to feel accepted and to feel like we belong. Sometimes the face of acceptance is sitting in a huddle with a bunch of hens, pecking another hen's eyes out.

My bottom line: Even though I understand we, as humans (i.e. animals), are predisposed to act in certian ways, we do not have to give in to our base urges. I don't like it when other people talk about me in negative ways, but I do feel good when I learn that people said something positive about me. With all of this in mind, I try to be careful about what I say. Do I fail sometimes? Yes. I, too, can be a catty bitch when provoked under the right circumstances.

Great post!

~ Rhi B.
http://rhibowman.wordpress.com

Charlene Ross
Charlene Ross
Posted Tue, 09/23/2008 - 18:03
I agree with Amy wholeheartedly and was going to say everything she said - you were talking about the brat and his parents inability (or unwillingness) to parent him - not about how mommy drinks because daddy is banging the babysitter! Give yourself a break. I wish I could say I never gossip but I do. I TRY not to, but I do. Although I will say that as I get older I do it less. I'm becoming a kinder, gentler version of my young self and I much say I like the older me much better.