Straight or Gay...why do we need labels?

HERvotesApril is National Poetry MonthMay Feel Goodskirt! on Facebook
MICROSKIRTSMICROSKIRTS
Ms
http://greencoffeebeanextract.wetpaint.com/
Natural anti ageing product
http://www.zimbio.com/Anti-aging/articles/X3kx7KMhMKX/Derma+Pure+Cream+Reviews+Dermapure+Anti+Aging
Effortless Method To Get Slim&Trim Body
http://greencoffeebeanextract.wetpaint.com/
Rapid weight loss Program Review
http://free.yudu.com/item/details/528604/Effortless-Method-To-Get-Slim-Trim-Body
Now Easy Get Rid of Wrinkles
http://www.zimbio.com/Health/articles/sb-iNtbdvZp/Green+Coffee+Bean+Extract+Review+Buy+Green
235
views

Straight or Gay...why do we need labels?

I was inspired this morning after reading one of the featured blogs ("Are Men Making Women Gay). It is completely true that our culture has shifted with regard to the acceptance of sexual orientation but to suggest that this shift is in any way connected to men is appalling to me. In fact, I could easily write an entire blog bashing Dr. Sax and his research, but what good would that do? However, before I move on, let me ask a very simple question...does anyone have the power to "make" someone gay? It's idiotic to me that a well-educated researcher would even suggest such a thing! 

A lot of energy and passion has been expended on the whole "nature versus nurture" debate as it relates to sexual orientation. My question is: does it really matter? Our society is so bent on labeling everything, from political affiliation to religious beliefs, we want to fit everyone into tidy little boxes. And, truth be told, once we put someone into a box what usually follows is some type of judgement. We all do it. Take a moment and read the following labels one by one, pausing in between, and see what immediately comes to your mind: 

     CHRISTIAN

     LESBIAN

     REPUBLICAN

     VEGAN

Chances are what followed in your mind after you read each of the above words was a string of characteristics describing how you view a person wearing that label. Depending on your world view those descriptions were either positive or negative in nature. I wonder how often we miss getting to know someone on a deeper level because we put them into a box with a label on it? Imagine with me for a moment what our culture would be like without labels. What if how you vote or which God you follow didn't describe who you are but rather, simply, something you believe in? What if a woman fell in love with another woman not because she's a lesbian but because she was attracted to the qualities and unique characteristics of that other person? What if you could be a vegan without owning a pair of Birkenstocks and continuing to shave your legs?

When we label someone we devalue them in many ways. We take all that is unique about them and squeeze it into a neat little box that makes us somehow more comfortable. One of the great things about living in America is that we are not forced into a belief system by our government. America is the land of the free where life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness is our right as a citizen. Unfortunately we, as individuals, try to dictate what it means to be free and make judgements about whether another's pursuit of happiness is acceptable to us. The whole labeling thing is like a virus that feeds on itself. Those that are gay fight to be accepted only to turn around and judge straight people for being narrow minded. Christians are passionate about the love of Jesus until they walk past an abortion clinic and suddenly they become angry and hateful. When does it end?

I made a decision a couple of years ago to throw away my labeling gun. For a while I still kept the little pocket sized one in my purse just in case I needed it but I've since discarded that one too. Sometimes I find myself unconsciously reaching for it...in fact I was looking all over the house for a label gun after reading about Dr. Sax's research on men making women gay this morning! It's not easy to keep people out of boxes but it is much more liberating and enjoyable.

    

skirt!setter
Skirtsetter

2 Comments

Straight or Gay...why do we need labels?

Great post!

 I loved this!  Yeah, why put everyone (and ourselves) in little boxes?  Labels are never the whole of who anybody is.  Totally agree.

 

I wrote the original post and I should clarify a couple of things.  First, his research was just on what labels people used on themselves.  Basically lots of girls said, "I'm lesbian or bi," and he speculated on his about why the uptick in that self-identification, but there wasn't much evidence one way or the other about his take on why.  Also he didn't use the phase "make women gay."  That was me mocking, since the only major scenarios he considered for women's self-identification were based on men.  I don't think he really believes anyone "makes" anyone else gay, more that he thinks many women explore/consider same-sex relationships in response to some experience with men.  I don't think he's a bad person, just that he's coming from a male-centric perspective, and can't seem to imagine that women might not view our sexuality from that perspective too.

 

On a personal note, I've been thinking a lot about labels lately myself.  I notice that within my little San Francisco world my friends don't label ourselves as much (at least with sexuality) or we make up our own labels.  But when I leave that and don't chose a label from myself, people assume a label for me.  Then I worry that if I don't correct them I'll be lying/misleading, and as much as I'd like to give my paragraph description of myself, a few labels is all there's room for.

 

Maybe next time I should direct them to this post.  :)


Straight or Gay...why do we need labels?

Great Comments!

I really appreciated your clarification about what the "researcher guy" said. Obviously I got my panties in a twist about all the ramifications of what I thought he was concluding. And, that being said, it often seems as though men view the world from a very ego-male-centric standpoint, which really irks me (in case you couldn't tell).

I see, and feel, what you're saying about labels in your last paragraph. Even if we make a choice to function without labels our society doesn't function in that same way and so, in a sense, we're screwed. And, honestly, I don't have an answer for that. I have very little black and white in my world but that's not true for most people...so, if you're in love with a woman then you MUST be a lesbian because that's the way it works...you know?

One thing that's really helped me walk through these things is reading some Buddhist teachings (which, given your skirt! name, I trust you are familiar with the things I've read). Specifically the teaching on unattachment - not being attached to what others think or how they react - has been a bedrock for me. But...that's a whole other blog post(:

Thanks for taking the time to write the original post which inspired me and to comment on mine(:


 
May 2012 Featured Artist - Ashley Barron
Cover Prose for May 2012 The To-Go Issue


Enter your email below and have
skirt! sent straight to your inbox!

Daily Muse
   A bit of daily
inspiration

Weekly Newsletter
   The best of skirt! weekly

Monthly Newsletter
   See what's happening monthly