Highly illogical, captain

HERvotesApril is National Poetry MonthMay Feel Goodskirt! on Facebook
MICROSKIRTSMICROSKIRTS
Effortless Method To Get Slim&Trim Body
http://greencoffeebeanextract.wetpaint.com/
Rapid weight loss Program Review
http://free.yudu.com/item/details/528604/Effortless-Method-To-Get-Slim-Trim-Body
Now Easy Get Rid of Wrinkles
http://www.zimbio.com/Health/articles/sb-iNtbdvZp/Green+Coffee+Bean+Extract+Review+Buy+Green
Rapid weight loss Program Review
https://bitly.com/KRqwll+
Rapid weight loss Program Review
https://bitly.com/KRqwll+
833
views

Highly illogical, captain

What does the future hold for women's rights and the advancement of equality?  According to the makers of the most recent Star Trek film, not a whole hell of a lot.  If you aren't completely swept away by all the dazzle of the film or Captain Kirk's epic forehead, maybe it will occur to you that despite a decent amount of diversity in the sense of the extra-limbed and lime-green extraterrestial variety, the deck is still awfully y-chromosome heavy. 

Spoiler alert - I saw the film and I'm about to rain all over your parade:

The film starts out by setting up an alternate reality whereby Captain Nero travels back to the date of Captain Kirk's birth and kills Kirk's father, hence setting up Kirk to be the renegade child later seen speeding down a dirt road in Iowa back-country, a scene which, I'm convinced, was included in order to have a product placement for Nokia phone.  Switch scene and we see a young Mr. Spock being ridiculed by his Vulcan peers, only to have him lash out and bloody the nose of the offending bully.  If this doesn't get your eyes rolling, fastforward to how both Spock and Kirk enlist in Star Fleet. 

Oh, these two rapscallion youth! 

Mr. Spock could have gone to the academy, but in an act of defiance chooses to go into Star fleet, you can just feel the room chill as he tells them "live long and prosper" with an undeniably human "f-you" undertone. 

Kirk, meanwhile, is trying to mack on one young Lt. Ohura in the bar. Another product placement - two Budweiser Classics make up an order of other-worldly drinks oh, and a shot of Jack, please.    Ohura, while not interested in the future Captain's protruding forehead, none-the-less smiles and flirts while he slathers on the machismo.  Kirk quickly finds himself in a testosterone driven show of male dominance when other would-be starfleet officers rush to assert that Ohura is in fact their property - beat it, towny.  The resulting tussel ends in Captain Pike giving fatherly advice to young James T. about how his father blah, blah, blah.  Haven't I seen this scene in like *every* military film, ever?

Young Jim makes it to Starfleet where there are apparently only two ladies worth getting speaking lines, Ohura, and a La Perla clad green bimbo (Ohura's roommate).  Oh, Jim, something about your giant forehead just makes my green knees go weak.

From there, the action actually begins and let's face it, it was dazzling.  We had the classic lines "Jim, I'm a doctor not a physicist!" (Dr. Leonard "Bones" McCoy) "Live long and prosper" (Mr. "I don't have a first name" Spock), "I'm giving her all I've got, captain" (Scotty) and the classic nameless ensign who goes along with Mr. Sulu and Captain Kirk for a mission only to meet a tragic death and a few other goodies. 

After watching the film, I'm left with a few thoughts and questions, like "why was kirk such a perv?"  Really, in the original, Kirk was a renowned womanizer, but he didn't go around checking out everything that shimmied around in an impractically short skirt.  Within the first half of the film, he'd "accidentally" gotten to second base with Ohura who rather than smacking him back to last Thursday, just gasps.  Also, have film makers completely lost the concept of nuance and subtelty?  Was it absolutely necessary to reintroduce all of the classic characters in the first half of the film?  Couldn't we, the audience, been left with some possibility that there might be a future where Scotty, Bones, Ohura, Chekov, and Sulu eventually joined the crew?  Was it absolutely necessary that they all happen to be on the enterprise as their first ship out of the training academy?  Also, do women in the future not have pants?  Ok, so maybe they want to keep some of the stuff from the original show, like flip-phone-esque communicators, but I don't remember the bridge being quite so glaringly white.  While they were redesigning the deck couldn't they have included, just maybe, one or two extra ladies?    And why were all the bad guys all GUYS? 

In the future, can we expect that women only play trite and stereotypical roles of wives, mothers, damsels in distress and harlots?  Given the advances women have made over the past several decades since the original t.v. show, this total cliched future seems higly illogical.

Skirtsetter

5 Comments

Highly illogical, captain

"Nameless ensign?" Jess,

"Nameless ensign?" Jess, don't you know? Thats what's known as a "Red Shirt."

I called the bridge "iPod White." I'm surprised there wasn't some version of an iPod on the bridge, given the rest of the product placement.

**SPOILERS**

What bugged me the most, was the complete rewriting of history. Yes, Star Trek has frequently visited the idea of time travel, and screwing the timeline, but they always managed to fix it by the end. Not this time. It's as if JJ Abrams said "Gene, you wrote a pretty good story, but I think I could have done it better. See?" I mean really, if Spock's mother is dead, how can she tell Kirk that even she can't pronounce Spock's first name. And don't get me started on Captain Pike. That is not how he ends up in a wheelchair. And if Nurse Chapel finds out about Spock and Uhura, she's gonna have a fit!

Oh, and Winona Ryder? What were they thinking?

Gene Roddenberry really was somewhat of a feminist. He wanted an equal mix in the crew with a female 1st officer. The studios said no. The later series were much better on this score. I liked Voyager especially, and not just because it had a woman captain. The whole concept and flow of the series was woman driven. With the Captain, Be'lana, Kess and later Seven, the women frequently left the men in their wake. That was writing!


Highly illogical, captain

Voyager

Plus, male pregnancy! Jessica.M

Highly illogical, captain

Brava!! I love it: "Do women

Brava!! I love it: "Do women in the future not have pants?" LMAO! I had this same kind of convo years ago with my guy friends when we all went out to see Lord of the Rings. I was like, um, where are all the women? You know, besides Liv Tyler who spoke all in whispers and wore white. Hmm. The guys were supremely pissed that I had an opinion at all about it. In fact, my friend who went to Harvard said. "Oh Sara, don't get caught up in that feminism crap. It's all crap." Immediately, I did not think he was cute anymore.~Sara

Highly illogical, captain

The Hero's Journey

My partner said something to the effect of me being upset because it didn't cater to my "special interest group". He got a big dose of the hairy eyeball because I don't exactly consider women to be a special interest group. Watch any movie about a group of friends called on a journey across the known world and it can go either two ways, if it's all men it's a film for people of all ages and both sexes, watch a film about a group of friends called on a journey across the known world and it's all women then it's a chick flick and stars Britney Spears. Jessica.M

Highly illogical, captain

So effing true!! I had

So effing true!! I had pretty much the same convo with my ex (when he was still my boyfriend) a while back. I was like, if it's an "epic hero's journey" it's Star Trek and stars men, if it's the same concept and stars women, it's called "The Sisterhood of the Travelling Pants" and doesn't mean diddly squat to mainstream society (I guess "mainstream society" is code for men???). That's what I'm picking up. Damn, it pisses me off. And throw your partner a hairy eyeball from me, too: women are sooo not "special interest." We're more than 50 percent of the population. That would technically make men the minority...men are the special interest group.~Sara

 
May 2012 Featured Artist - Ashley Barron
Cover Prose for May 2012 The To-Go Issue


Enter your email below and have
skirt! sent straight to your inbox!

Daily Muse
   A bit of daily
inspiration

Weekly Newsletter
   The best of skirt! weekly

Monthly Newsletter
   See what's happening monthly