Is Yoga Anti-Christian?
By BeckyB, Friday, October 8, 2010, 4 comments
These recent comments are getting all kinds of attention right now.
Long-time yoginis are never shocked when these ideas are expressed because well....it's kinda true. Yoga does take you to new heights. Is that a bad thing?
I have practiced yoga for over 3 years now. I have practiced it in various local gyms and studios. I have gone to classes in churches and rec centers. I have sat beside practicing Hindus who prayed before and after class. I have sat beside nice Christian ladies who discussed the pot-luck at church last week.
Here's what I've come up with.....
Yoga, like many activities, is viewed in many ways by many different people. For some, it is good exercise and a means of stress reduction. For some, it's a fun activity with a social component. For some, it is an extension of their religious practice with far-reaching meditative goals. For some, it is a small component of their overall mental and physical health regimen.
For me? It's all of the above.
I came to yoga during a time in my life when I was very depressed, lacking in flexibility and slightly overweight. Yoga helped me come to peace with all those things. Yoga, at one time, was the only thing that got me out of bed every morning. It was an activity that made me feel good and pulled away all those things that hurt me......both mentally and physically. Yoga helped me find my strength. It helped me discover my body. Yoga taught me how to breathe, educated my sexuality and gave me a non-medication way to work through panic attacks.
I think, at least in some small way, that yoga helped save my life.
And yes, from a religous perspective, I have reached great heights in my practice with my breathing, postures and meditation. Was I close to God? To the Hindi god(s)? To some Higher Power? I'm not sure. But I can say, the feelings and release I have experienced in yoga have never been found in church in all my life. Not by me anyway.
Does that make me bad? Anti-Christian? Believing in false gods?
Well....I hope not.
But what's more important than all that is what yoga does make me feel. When I finish practicing, I feel strong. I breathe deeply. I don't have bad thoughts. I don't ruminate in my past hurt. I smile more. I wave people into traffic. I eat well. Basically, I feel great!
Now since I'm not a Fundamentalist, I'm not sure if any of that is okay to say and feel. But to be fair, how can it be wrong? If yoga can get me to those places, can't it do the same thing for practicing Christians? Or really anyone who wants to get to greater understanding with anything in their lives? Yoga may have its roots in Hinduism, but it has stretched its fingers out to many other cultures. Just like sharing the foods, religions and social habits of other cultures, yoga opens us up to a small piece of our vast, beautiful world.
I, for one, am all the better for it.
~Namaste~


















4 Comments
I'm starting to think
I for one am starting the question how Christian Christians are. For the love of Pete...Yoga is a centuries old practice that benefits EVERYBODY. What is the big threat?
Christianity and yoga
You have a point, EB.
I have been contemplating beginning yoga for a while now. I need some centering and stress reduction, I need some quiet time and thoughtfulness.
Interestingly enough, I feel I need to find this calm, thoughtful place because typically my thoughts are so scattered and my mind so busy that when I pray (daily) to God, my mind wanders to everything, and that's not how I want to pray.
The fundamentalists and the groups protesting military funerals... claiming the deaths are God's punishment for homosexuality... they've missed the point of Christianity.
We're supposed to love one another. That's the biggie.
Sorry, I've digressed.
Yoga is a form of exercise for both the mind and the body. It improves health and reduces stress-without drugs. Really...how can that be a bad thing?
Agreed.
"The feelings and release I have experienced in yoga have never been found in church in all my life."
I feel the exact same way.
Personally, I don't even associate my yoga practice with anything spiritual, necessarily. I feel like it's me connecting with my body, stretching the limits of what it can do and giving it my full attention for an hour a week. I don't think about work or dinner or bills, I just concentrate on the position at hand and listen to my breath.
Namaste Becky!
Great Blog. It was very well thought out and well written. Just beautiful. It is obvious that you are an incredibly peaceful person.
It's interesting. When I was pregnant with my first child 14 years ago I started taking pre-natal yoga. It was wonderful. Back in those days I would get massages quite often and I was telling my masseuse (who I'd been going to for about 12 years) that I was taking yoga. I thought she would be so happy - this was the woman that introduced me to herbal medicine, warned me about the dangers of caffeine, and taught me the importance of daily stretching. She immediately stiffened up & became upset. She was a born again Christian and told my "yoga is a religion, they will try to convert you."
Uh...my yoga teacher was Jewish. I think it's pretty safe to say that Jewish people aren't out there trying to convert the masses through yoga! I've had yoga teachers of many different faiths and honestly I don't even know what religion most of my teachers are. I practice yoga on and off since then and have never experienced the intense benefits that you describe, but they sound lovely - one more thing I really should focus on finding time for.
And yes, I find too that many Christians do not behave in a Christian-like manner and that is truly sad.
Participate More